Vivant· Is the village alive?

Montchal

Loire · CC de Forez-Est · INSEE 42148

A school and somewhere to eat or drink, but no food shop.

Few services 34.7/100 · confidence: high· Better served than 72 % of the {n|commune|communes} of a similar size.

Identity

Montchal (INSEE 42148) is in Loire (42), part of CC de Forez-Est. Population 512 (2023). [1]

INSEE density class: Rural à habitat dispersé (level 6). [2]

Data vintages: INSEE BPE 2025 · INSEE SIRENE 2026-09 · INSEE census (RP) 2023 · INSEE COG 2026 · INSEE density grid 2026 · DATAtourisme 2026-10-22.

Permanent link: https://vivantrural.com/en/fr/42148-montchal

Vitality score

Vitality score 34.7/100 — Few services (model fr-v0.2).

Confidence: high.

Better served than 72 % of the 17,733 communes of a similar size.

Compare this with communes of a similar size. The score measures how well a place is served relative to its own size band, and larger communes score higher as a rule — so it reads meaningfully against another village, and misleadingly against a town.

Measured but not scored in this model: Market. See the methodology for why.

ComponentValue (0–1)WeightContribution
Daily food0250
Social0.43208.65
Education0.63106.32
Health0100
Public & culture0.6353.16
Population trend0.81108.09
Housing mix0.6553.26

Services

What is here, at a glance

Food 0 of 6
Eating out 0 of 1
Cafés and bars 1 of 1
Schools 1 of 3
Health 0 of 4
Public services 1 of 1
Culture 1 of 2
Sport 1 of 2
Everyday services 0 of 3
Lodging 0 of 2
One square per service type, shaded by how many: none, one, a few, five or more. A blank square means none was counted — the sources do not distinguish “none here” from “not counted”.

A school and somewhere to eat or drink, but no food shop. [3,4]

2 × Café / bar (CHEZ MAUDE). [4]

1 × Primary school (élémentaire) (ECOLE PRIMAIRE RPI MONTCHAL COTTANCE). [3]

1 × Post office / agence postale (MONTCHAL AP). [3]

1 × Library (BIBLIOTHÈQUE - MONTCHAL). [3]

1 × Gym / sports hall (SALLE POLYVALENTE). [3]

Not found in the commune: Bakery (boulangerie), Butcher (boucherie), Grocery (épicerie / supérette), Supermarket, Restaurant, Nursery school (maternelle), GP (médecin généraliste), Pharmacy. [3,4]

All 25 service types, with per-source counts
TypeCountNamesSources
Bakery (boulangerie)0INSEE BPE 0 / INSEE SIRENE 0 [3,4]
Butcher (boucherie)0INSEE BPE 0 / INSEE SIRENE 0 [3,4]
Grocery (épicerie / supérette)0INSEE BPE 0 / INSEE SIRENE 0 [3,4]
Supermarket0INSEE BPE 0 / INSEE SIRENE 0 [3,4]
Cheese shop (fromagerie)0INSEE SIRENE 0 [4]
Fishmonger0INSEE BPE 0 / INSEE SIRENE 0 [3,4]
Restaurant0INSEE SIRENE 1 / INSEE BPE 0 [4]
Café / bar2CHEZ MAUDEINSEE SIRENE 2 [4]
Nursery school (maternelle)0INSEE BPE 0 [3]
Primary school (élémentaire)1ECOLE PRIMAIRE RPI MONTCHAL COTTANCEINSEE BPE 1 [3]
Collège0INSEE BPE 0 [3]
GP (médecin généraliste)0INSEE BPE 0 [3]
Pharmacy0INSEE BPE 0 / INSEE SIRENE 0 [3,4]
Nurse0INSEE BPE 0 [3]
Dentist0INSEE BPE 0 [3]
Post office / agence postale1MONTCHAL APINSEE BPE 1 [3]
Library1BIBLIOTHÈQUE - MONTCHALINSEE BPE 1 [3]
Cinema0INSEE BPE 0 [3]
Gym / sports hall1SALLE POLYVALENTEINSEE BPE 1 [3]
Swimming pool0INSEE BPE 0 [3]
Bank0INSEE BPE 0 [3]
Hairdresser0INSEE SIRENE 1 / INSEE BPE 0 [4]
Fuel station0INSEE BPE 0 / INSEE SIRENE 0 [3,4]
Hotel0INSEE BPE 0 / INSEE SIRENE 0 [3,4]
Campsite0INSEE BPE 0 / INSEE SIRENE 0 [3,4]

Market and village life

A market is recorded here, but no source gives the day. [5]

Trajectory

1968: 493 2023: 512 axis from zero, so the slope compares with any other commune

Population 478 (2012) → 512 (2023): 7.1 % over 10 years. [6,1]

Population 391 (1990) → 512 (2023): 30.9 % over 30 years. [7,1]

Dwellings (2023): 322, of which 17.4 % second homes and 11.8 % vacant. [8]

Access and surroundings

Which way the everyday services lie

2.5 km5 kmBakery — 3.5 km SW (Cottance)GP — 3.9 km W (Bussières)Pharmacy — 3.9 km W (Bussières)Food shop — 4.1 km SE (Panissières)
In the commune Primary school Bakery — 3.5 km SWGP — 3.9 km WPharmacy — 3.9 km WFood shop — 4.1 km SE Straight-line, from the mairie, in the direction given. Services in the same town share a spoke. Distance is not travel time: a pass or an estuary can double it.

Bakery (Cottance): 3.5 km to the south-west (straight line). [9]

Food shop (Panissières): 4.1 km to the south-east (straight line). [10]

GP (Bussières): 3.9 km to the west (straight line). [11]

Pharmacy (Bussières): 3.9 km to the west (straight line). [11]

Primary school (Montchal): 0 km to the south-west (straight line). [12]

Climate

Where this sits nationally

Each track runs from the 5th to the 95th percentile of the 34,141 communes with that measurement; the tick is the median. A value beyond either end sits at the end and is marked ▸.

An average of 16 days a year at or above 30 °C and 64 days at or below 0 °C, over 18 complete years in 1995–2024. [13]

Measured at the ROZIER-EN-DONZY weather station, 3.9 km away at 530 m; the village itself is at 647 m. [13]

The village sits 117 m above the station, so each day's reading was shifted by 6.06 °C per km of altitude before the days were counted. Expect the result to be within about 0.68 °C. [13]

Muggy days — a dew point at or above 18 °C — average 2 days a summer. [13]

Humidity measured at ROZIER-EN-DONZY, 3.9 km away at 530 m, over 13 summers. [13]

That station sits 117 m below the village, so each day's humidity was shifted by 3.69 °C per km before the muggy days were counted. [13]

An average of 878 mm of rain a year, spread over 117 days — about 7.5 mm on a day it rains. [13]

Rainfall measured at PANISSIERES, 2.9 km away at 614 m. Rainfall is not adjusted for altitude: unlike temperature it has no simple gradient to correct by. [13]

Uncertainties

No specific uncertainties flagged.

References

  1. INSEE census (RP) 2023 — 42148/2023
  2. INSEE density grid 2026
  3. INSEE BPE 2025
  4. INSEE SIRENE 2026-09
  5. DATAtourisme 2026-02— https://data.datatourisme.fr/13/4211f1cf-3441-3841-800d-a1e02c828b34— “Marché hebdomadaire”(unverified)
  6. INSEE census (RP) 2023 — 42148/2012
  7. INSEE census (RP) 2023 — 42148/1990
  8. INSEE census (RP) 2023 — 42148/logement/2023
  9. INSEE BPE 2025 — 42073
  10. INSEE BPE 2025 — 42165
  11. INSEE BPE 2025 — 42029
  12. INSEE BPE 2025 — 42148
  13. Météo-France daily climatology 1995-2024

Villages like this one

Matched on size, density, second homes and which everyday shops and services are present — not on the score, so a village of the same kind that is doing better or worse shows up rather than being hidden.

CommuneDeptDistancePopulationScoreBandClimate vs here
Saint-Front-la-Rivière24282 km W51126.8Few servicesWarmer summers and milder winters.Summers feel more humid.summer 72 % · winter 74 % · humidity 79 %
Teillet-Argenty03147 km W55530.5Few servicesWarmer summers and colder winters.Summers feel about as humid.summer 85 % · winter 84 % · humidity 93 %
Coulongé72376 km NW50629.1Few servicesSimilar summers, milder winters.Summers feel about as humid.summer 97 % · winter 76 % · humidity 93 %
Les Choux45252 km NW53033.6Few servicesWarmer summers, similar winters.Summers feel about as humid.summer 77 % · winter 97 % · humidity 93 %
Foissac12233 km SW45433.1Few servicesWarmer summers, similar winters.Summers feel about as humid.summer 49 % · winter 95 % · humidity 93 %
Lésigny86295 km NW52429.2Few servicesSimilar summers, milder winters.Summers feel about as humid.summer 87 % · winter 81 % · humidity 93 %
Order by distance instead
CommuneDeptDistancePopulationScoreBandClimate vs here
Teillet-Argenty03147 km W55530.5Few servicesWarmer summers and colder winters.Summers feel about as humid.summer 85 % · winter 84 % · humidity 93 %
Foissac12233 km SW45433.1Few servicesWarmer summers, similar winters.Summers feel about as humid.summer 49 % · winter 95 % · humidity 93 %
Les Choux45252 km NW53033.6Few servicesWarmer summers, similar winters.Summers feel about as humid.summer 77 % · winter 97 % · humidity 93 %
Saint-Front-la-Rivière24282 km W51126.8Few servicesWarmer summers and milder winters.Summers feel more humid.summer 72 % · winter 74 % · humidity 79 %
Lésigny86295 km NW52429.2Few servicesSimilar summers, milder winters.Summers feel about as humid.summer 87 % · winter 81 % · humidity 93 %
Coulongé72376 km NW50629.1Few servicesSimilar summers, milder winters.Summers feel about as humid.summer 97 % · winter 76 % · humidity 93 %

Sort and compare these on the full list →

…and in much the same climate

The same match on size and services, narrowed to communes whose summers, winters and summer humidity are all close to Montchal's. All three are required, so this section is absent for the 11.8 % of communes with no humidity station near enough to measure: two temperature axes alone cannot tell a muggy coast from a dry one.

CommuneDeptDistancePopulationScoreBandClimate vs here
Charrin58120 km NW60530Few servicesMuch the same temperatures.Summers feel about as humid.summer 97 % · winter 96 % · humidity 100 %
Saint-Germain-de-Joux01117 km E50737Few servicesMuch the same temperatures.Summers feel about as humid.summer 90 % · winter 88 % · humidity 86 %
Passavant-la-Rochère70272 km NE52430.2Few servicesMuch the same temperatures.Summers feel about as humid.summer 92 % · winter 95 % · humidity 100 %
Ormoy89243 km N63829Few servicesMuch the same temperatures.Summers feel about as humid.summer 95 % · winter 88 % · humidity 100 %
Yermenonville28366 km NW62132.6Few servicesMuch the same temperatures.Summers feel about as humid.summer 100 % · winter 97 % · humidity 93 %
Saints-en-Puisaye89215 km N54837.9Few servicesMuch the same temperatures.Summers feel about as humid.summer 100 % · winter 99 % · humidity 100 %